Fall Protection Systems - Simplified SafetyFall Protection Systems - Simplified Safety

Fall Protection
Safety Equipment
and Solutions

1.866.527.2275
Home Blog Rooftop Fall Protection Comparison: Solution Pros & Cons

Fall Protection Blog

Rooftop Fall Protection Comparison: Solution Pros & Cons

Overview

The scope of this document is to give you a general outline of the different pros and cons of the fall protection systems that we offer.

There are two principal forms of fall protection covered in this document: Passive and Active.

  • Passive fall protection is mostly closely aligned with guardrail. Guardrail requires minimal inspection and virtually no training. Simply put, passive fall protection requires no action from the rooftop worker once the system is installed.
  • Active fall protection is typically aligned with horizontal lifelines and anchor points. It requires training, maintenance, inspection, and management on an on-going basis. Most importantly, it requires action from the user each time it is used.

For a complete list of the different methods of fall protection see this page on our web site: What is the difference between different types of fall protection?

Pricing information is based upon estimated pricing of typical systems as of September 2011, our assumption is that price changes affect all systems equally.

skip to downloadable version

Non-Penetrating Rooftop Guardrails

KeeGuard Rooftop Guardrail KeeGuard Rooftop Guardrail

The best example of non-penetrating rooftop guardrail is the KeeGuard Rooftop Guardrail system. It is a counter-balanced system that is easy to install and can be adapted to just about any rooftop obstacle. Easily assembled by a two-man crew, it can protect large sections of roof perimeter or provide smaller sections of spot protection.

Costs

Installation Costs

Starts at $50.00 / linear foot + 16 man hours for ever 600’ linear feet

Training Costs

No training required

Pros and Cons

Pros

Cons

  • Easy to install, no specialized training is required
  • Can easily be modified on site no welding required
  • No ongoing maintenance or training is required
  • Versitile - Can be built around existing rooftop obstacles such as HVAC units and roofs of varying heights
  • Durable 100% galvanized system
  • Tested for OSHA compliance
  • Architectural “look and feel”
  • Initial product cost is higher than other systems

 

Parapet Guardrail

Parapet Guardrail Parapet Guardrail

Parapet guardrails are permanent guardrails that are attached directly to the side or top of a roof parapet. Parapet guardrails are less expensive than non-penetrating guardrail but will require more labor costs and a suitable parapet to install.

Costs

Installation Costs

$28.00 / linear foot + 32 man hours for every 600 linear feet

Training Costs

No training required

Pros and Cons

Pros

Cons

  • Lower linear foot cost than a counter-balanced solution.
  • Easy to install, attaches directly to the parapet, avoiding penetration of the roof membrane.
  • No ongoing training is required
  • Can be built around existing rooftop obstacles such as HVAC units and roofs of varying heights
  • Suitable parapet is required
  • Railing has to be placed on parapet, making it more visible from below.
  • Higher installation costs
  • Special labor is required in most cases for proper sealing of penetrations
  • Penetrations may need to be maintained

 

Horizontal Lifeline

Horizontal Lifeline Horizontal Lifeline

Horizontal lifeline systems are built along a particular path of the rooftop. The rooftop worker ties off to the system through the use of a harness and lanyard. Horizontal lifelines must be installed and maintained by specialized personnel. OSHA also requires all employees using the system to undergo competent person training for each system. Rescue plans and other safety management overheads are involved in all active fall protection systems.

Costs

Installation Costs

$40.00 / linear foot (varies greatly by location and configuration)
$100-200 equipment cost per person

Training Costs

Competent person training, system training

Pros and Cons

Pros

Cons

  • Lower cost of product than most guardrail solutions
    Not visible from the ground
  • Can be used in some circumstance where passive solutions will not work
  • Allows for more mobility around a roof than standard anchor points
  • Must be installed by certified installers
  • Ongoing maintenance
  • OSHA competent person training required by all employees using the system
  • Inspection required before every use
  • Requires the employee to wear fall protection equipment and properly tie off to the system.
  • Ongoing purchase of PPE (harnesses, lanyards, etc.)
  • Requires valid rescue plan
  • Requires attention from management to document and all of the above and validate that the safety plan is being followed.
  • Limits productivity to workers

 

Non-Penetrating Tie Off Anchor Points

Non penetrating tie off anchor point Non penetrating tie off anchor point

Solutions such as the Kee Safety Weightanka and the Guardian Hammer fit into this category of portable, non-penetrating tie off points. These products allow workers to tie off in a particular location, but gives them the freedom to move the system when it is needed elsewhere.

Costs

Installation Costs

$3-4,000 for unit and one persons equipment
$100/linear foot (assuming a unit can protect 30 feet)

Training Costs

Competent person training, system training

Pros and Cons

Pros

Cons

  • Systems are portable and can be moved
  • Relatively low cost of entry
  • Not visible from the ground
  • Does not penetrate the roof
  • OSHA competent person training required by all employees using the system
  • Inspection required before every use
  • Requires the employee to wear fall protection equipment and properly tie off to the system.
  • Ongoing purchase of PPE (harnesses, lanyards, etc.)
  • Requires valid rescue plan
  • Higher risk of incorrect use.
  • Requires attention from management to document and all of the above and validate that the safety plan is being followed.
  • Limits productivity to workers
  • Adds additional work time to each job for setting up and tearing down the anchor point.
  • Allows limited access before needing to be repositioned.

 

Download this Guide

This guide is available as a downloadable PDF.

 Downloadable PDF - Rooftop Fall Protection - Comparison

For additional reading on the difference in short-term and long-term costs between these two solutions, please see this series of posts on our web site:

Seven Ways to Save on Safety (Part 1)
Seven Ways to Save on Safety (Part 2)
Seven Ways to Save on Safety (Part 3)

This post contributed by:

Chris Pollock

Simplified Safety / General Manager

.(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)

http://www.simplifiedsafety.com/

Chris enjoys investigating the latest safety products and finding ways to help people stay safe while working. You can follow him on Twitter and .

This post contributed by:

Dan Wampler

Simplified Safety / Sales Manager

.(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)

1.866.527.2275

http://www.simplifiedsafety.com/

Dan's experience in the safety industry will be an asset to you and your company as you evaluate safety products and services. Dan has worked on rooftops across the country to help customers arrive at the ideal fall protection solution. Reach out to Dan to discuss safety standards, equipment and services.

comments powered by Disqus